Bay Street Theater welcomed a full house once again as “My First Ex-Husband” returned for a special encore performance, reaffirming the production’s popularity with audiences in Sag Harbor. Held on Monday, August 26, the event featured television personality and Bay Street Board of Trustees member Joy Behar, who took the stage alongside a talented cast for an evening that blended humor, emotion, and thoughtful storytelling. The encore performance marked another successful chapter for the production, which has continued to draw enthusiastic support throughout the summer season.
Joining Behar on stage were acclaimed performers Susie Essman, Tovah Feldshuh, and Sherri Shepherd. Together, the four performers delivered a series of engaging monologues that explored the ups and downs of relationships with wit, honesty, and heartfelt emotion. Their performances resonated with the audience, creating an atmosphere filled with laughter, reflection, and appreciation for the show’s relatable themes.
My First Ex-Husband is Joy Behar’s newest theatrical project and is built around a collection of monologues that balance comedy with poignant observations about life and love. Rather than telling a single continuous story, the production presents a series of individual voices and experiences, allowing each performer to bring a unique perspective to the stage. The combination of sharp humor and emotional depth has become one of the defining qualities of the show, helping it connect with audiences and contributing to its strong reception.
The encore performance also represented another milestone for Bay Street Theater, as the production sold out the venue for the second time this summer. The strong demand for tickets reflected the continued interest in the show and the popularity of its cast. Beyond entertaining audiences, the event also served an important purpose by benefiting Bay Street Theater and supporting its ongoing artistic programming and community initiatives. The successful fundraising performance highlighted the theater’s commitment to presenting quality productions while engaging supporters through special events featuring well-known performers.
The production is led by producers Rose Caiola, Cyrene Esposito, and Tracy Mitchell in collaboration with Bay Street Theater. Their partnership has helped bring My First Ex-Husband to the stage and deliver a production that combines recognizable talent with engaging material. The collaboration has played an important role in the show’s successful run and its ability to attract sold-out audiences during the summer season.
Adding to the excitement of the evening was the presence of several celebrity guests in attendance. Among those spotted at the event were Jon Hamm and Lorraine Bracco, along with a number of other notable attendees who came to support the performance. Their appearance contributed to the star-studded atmosphere surrounding the event and underscored the show’s appeal within the entertainment community.
With another packed audience, an accomplished cast, and an enthusiastic response from theatergoers, the encore performance of My First Ex-Husband once again demonstrated why the production has become one of Bay Street Theater’s standout events of the summer. Combining comedy, heartfelt storytelling, and a charitable mission, the evening offered an entertaining experience while raising support for one of Sag Harbor’s most respected cultural institutions.